Why Choosing the Right Dog Treat Matters
If you’re a dog owner like me, you know treats are more than just tasty rewards—they’re essential tools for training, bonding, and supporting our pups’ overall health. But let’s face it: not all dog treats are created equal. Some are loaded with artificial ingredients, while others barely provide nutritional value. The best dog treats go beyond flavor; they support digestion, joint health, skin, and coat, all while being easy on your pup’s stomach.
In this article, I’ll walk you through a detailed review of five popular dog treats from Tractor Supply, one of the most trusted stores for pet products. From single-ingredient jerky strips to rawhide sticks for dental care, these treats cater to different needs—whether you’ve got a picky pup, a senior with joint issues, or a young energetic chewer.
So, if you’ve been overwhelmed by the rows of treat bags or confused by vague labels, don’t worry. This guide breaks down everything you need to know—ingredients, benefits, pros/cons, and ideal use cases—to help you find the perfect treat for your furry friend.
What to Look for in High-Quality Dog Treats
Before diving into specific products, let’s quickly talk about what sets a great dog treat apart from a mediocre one. Here are some must-haves:
✅ Key Ingredients
- Real meat as the first ingredient (chicken, duck, beef, salmon)
- No artificial flavors or preservatives
- Minimal processing
- Grain-free or corn-free options for sensitive pups
- Added functional benefits (omega-3s, glucosamine, etc.)
⚠️ What to Avoid
- Meat “by-products” or “meal”
- Artificial dyes and sweeteners
- High sugar or filler content
- Overly hard treats for puppies or senior dogs
With that in mind, let’s dive into the top dog treats from Tractor Supply and see how they stack up.
Waggin’ Train Sensitive Stomach Duck Jerky Tenders
If your dog has a sensitive stomach, Waggin’ Train Sensitive Stomach Duck Jerky Tenders might be the gentle-yet-tasty solution you’ve been looking for.
Product Highlights
- Main Ingredient: 100% real duck breast
- Size: 12 oz bag
- Ingredient Count: Only 3 ingredients
- Price: $13.99 (or $13.29 with subscription)
Why It Stands Out
These jerky tenders are designed specifically for dogs with digestive sensitivities. The real duck meat makes them high in protein, while the prebiotic fiber supports gut health. The best part? No grains, corn, or artificial flavors—just clean, simple nutrition.
Pros
- Excellent for dogs with food sensitivities
- Tender texture, easy to chew
- Grain-free and corn-free
- Rich in protein, low in unnecessary fillers
Cons
- Slightly higher price per ounce
- May be too soft for aggressive chewers
Ideal For:
- Small to medium breeds
- Dogs with food allergies or tummy issues
- Picky eaters who love meaty flavors
Waggin’ Train Chicken Jerky Curls – Simply Protein
Want something simple and protein-packed? The Waggin’ Train Chicken Jerky Curls offer a wholesome treat with minimal fuss.
Product Highlights
- Main Ingredient: 100% real chicken breast
- Size: 3 oz bag
- Ingredient Count: Only 2 ingredients
- Price: $3.99
Why It Stands Out
This treat takes a no-nonsense approach—only chicken and vegetable glycerin. The curls are playful in shape but serious in quality. Dehydrated for a chewy bite, they’re easy to digest and full of flavor.
Pros
- Very affordable
- Ultra-simple ingredient list
- High-protein, low-carb
- No grains or artificial additives
Cons
- Smaller bag size—runs out quickly
- Not ideal for large breed training unless used in bulk
Ideal For:
- Dogs of all sizes
- Pet parents on a budget
- Fans of minimal-ingredient diets
Waggin’ Train Salmon Jerky Tenders – Skin & Coat Support
If your dog’s fur has been looking dull or their skin dry, Waggin’ Train Salmon Jerky Tenders might be just what they need.
Product Highlights
- Main Ingredient: 100% real salmon
- Size: 12 oz bag
- Ingredient Count: 4 ingredients
- Price: $13.99
Why It Stands Out
These jerky treats are packed with omega-3 fatty acids from real salmon to promote a shiny coat and healthy skin. Like others in the Waggin’ Train line, they’re free of grains, corn, and artificial stuff.
Pros
- Skin and coat benefits
- Rich in omega fatty acids
- Great flavor dogs love
- Limited ingredients for cleaner nutrition
Cons
- Fishy smell (expected but noticeable)
- Pricier than average jerky treats
Ideal For:
- Dogs with dry skin or dandruff
- Breeds known for thick coats (Huskies, Retrievers)
- Dogs with allergies to poultry
4health Hip & Joint Biscuits: Beef, Pea & Sweet Potato
Senior dogs or active breeds will benefit from 4health Special Care Hip and Joint Dog Treats.
Product Highlights
- Main Ingredient: Real beef
- Size: 48 oz bag (3 lbs)
- Key Nutrients: Glucosamine & Chondroitin
- Price: $11.99
Why It Stands Out
This formula targets joint support with glucosamine and chondroitin, key compounds used to improve mobility and reduce inflammation. The treats are also grain-free and fortified with pea and sweet potato for extra nutrients.
Pros
- Large quantity for a great price
- Supports hip and joint health
- No corn, wheat, or soy
- Crunchy texture dogs love
Cons
- Larger size may not be suitable for small breeds
- Not designed for puppies
Ideal For:
- Senior dogs
- Large and active breeds (Labs, Shepherds)
- Dogs with joint discomfort
Retriever Beef-Basted Munchy Sticks – Chewy Rawhide Value
Need a treat that keeps your dog chewing for longer? Retriever Beef-Basted Munchy Sticks are the budget-friendly, long-lasting option.
Product Highlights
- Main Ingredient: Rawhide with beef flavor
- Count: 100 sticks per bag
- Stick Size: 5 in. (12.7 cm)
- Price: $10.99
Why It Stands Out
These treats are perfect for dogs who love to chew. They help reduce tartar and plaque while satisfying natural chewing instincts. With 100 sticks in a single bag, it’s a fantastic value for training and reward.
Pros
- Great bulk value
- Promotes dental hygiene
- Long-lasting chew time
- Oven-baked with beefy flavor
Cons
- Rawhide can be hard to digest for some dogs
- Not ideal for dogs with sensitive stomachs
Ideal For:
- Aggressive chewers
- Medium to large breeds
- Dogs needing dental support
Comparing Ingredient Quality Across All Reviewed Treats
| Product | Main Protein | Grain-Free | Ingredient Count | Artificial Additives |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Duck Jerky Tenders | Duck | Yes | 3 | No |
| Chicken Jerky Curls | Chicken | Yes | 2 | No |
| Salmon Jerky Tenders | Salmon | Yes | 4 | No |
| Hip & Joint Biscuits | Beef | Yes | Complex | No |
| Munchy Sticks | Rawhide & Beef Flavor | No | Multiple | Minimal |
Best Treats by Dog Size and Life Stage
| Dog Type | Best Treat |
|---|---|
| Puppies | Chicken Jerky Curls (soft & simple) |
| Small Dogs | Salmon Jerky (easy to break up) |
| Medium Dogs | Duck Jerky Tenders |
| Large Dogs | Hip & Joint Biscuits or Munchy Sticks |
| Seniors | Hip & Joint Biscuits |
Best for Sensitive Stomachs and Allergies
If your pup struggles with digestion or allergies, go with:
- Duck Jerky Tenders (sensitive-stomach formula)
- Chicken Jerky Curls (only 2 ingredients)
- Salmon Jerky Tenders (no poultry or grain)
Dental Health: Which Treats Actually Help?
The Retriever Munchy Sticks are the clear winner here. Their rawhide texture helps clean teeth and reduce plaque. Use with caution in dogs prone to digestive issues.
If you prefer a softer treat that still promotes chewing, the Hip & Joint Biscuits are a safe option.
Pricing Breakdown: What You Get for Your Money
| Product | Size | Price | Cost/Oz |
|---|---|---|---|
| Duck Jerky Tenders | 12 oz | $13.99 | $1.17/oz |
| Chicken Jerky Curls | 3 oz | $3.99 | $1.33/oz |
| Salmon Jerky Tenders | 12 oz | $13.99 | $1.17/oz |
| Hip & Joint Biscuits | 48 oz | $11.99 | $0.25/oz |
| Munchy Sticks | 100 ct | $10.99 | ~$0.11/stick |
Smart Supply Savings & Subscription Options at Tractor Supply
Subscribing to Smart Supply saves you 5% on future orders and offers auto-ship convenience. Combine that with in-store pickup discounts (10% off) and you’re getting great value, especially if you have multiple dogs or go through treats quickly.
FAQs: Dog Treats Buying and Feeding Guide
1. How often should I give my dog treats?
Treats should make up no more than 10% of your dog’s daily caloric intake. Use them for training, reward, or as a supplement—not a meal replacement.
2. Are rawhide treats safe for all dogs?
Rawhide can pose a choking risk or digestive issue for some dogs. Always supervise your pet and consider their chewing habits before offering rawhide-based treats.
3. What’s the best treat for puppies?
Choose soft, small, and easy-to-digest options like Chicken Jerky Curls. Always check age recommendations on the label.
4. Can these treats help with allergies?
Yes. Treats like Duck Jerky and Salmon Jerky are grain-free and have limited ingredients, making them good choices for allergy-prone pups.
5. What’s the longest-lasting treat?
The Retriever Munchy Sticks are the most durable and ideal for heavy chewers.
Conclusion: The Best Treat for Your Dog Depends on Their Needs
At the end of the day, choosing the right treat isn’t just about what your dog likes—it’s about what their body needs. Whether you’re looking for joint support, dental health, allergy-safe ingredients, or just a tasty reward, there’s something here for every pup.
If I had to summarize:
- Best for Sensitive Dogs: Waggin’ Train Duck Jerky Tenders
- Best Value: Retriever Munchy Sticks (100 ct)
- Best for Health Support: 4health Hip & Joint Biscuits
- Best Minimalist Option: Chicken Jerky Curls
All these treats are available at Tractor Supply, both online and in-store, with savings through Smart Supply or curbside pickup.
So go ahead—reward your pup the smart, healthy way. They deserve it.
